JZ helps (a Florida injury law firm)

Call Now! (888) 594-3577Get a Free Consultation - 24 / 7
Se habla Español
Call Now! (888) 594-3577
Get a Free Consultation - 24 / 7
Se habla Español


  • Home
  • Videos
  • Blog
  • Settlements
    • Injury Settlements
    • Car Accident Settlements
    • Slip, Trip & Fall Settlements
    • GEICO Car Accident Settlements
    • Rear End Car Accident Settlements
    • Motorcycle Accidents Settlements
    • Truck Accident Settlements
    • State Farm Settlements
    • Uber Accidents
    • Progressive Insurance Settlements
    • Bike Accident Settlements
    • Pedestrian Hit By Car Settlements
    • Uninsured Motorist Insurance Settlements
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • See Inside
    • Types of Injuries We’ve Dealt With
    • List of Cities Where We’ve Settled Cases
    • Press Room
  • Fees
    • Our Fees
    • Referral Fees
  • Cases We Handle
    • All personal injury cases
    • Car Accidents
    • Truck Accidents
    • Uber Accidents
    • Slip and Falls and Injuries on Property
    • Cruise Accidents
    • Florida Motorcycle Accidents
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • Accidents at a Store
    • DUI Accidents
    • Accidental or Wrongful Death
    • Florida Condo and Apartment Accidents
    • Hotel Accidents
  • Get a Free Case Review
  • Reviews
You are here: Home / Slip, Trip and Fall / Jury Says Target Didn’t Cause Guest’s Slip and Fall Injuries; Guest Loses

October 31, 2015 By Justin Ziegler, Lawyer Leave a Comment

Jury Says Target Didn’t Cause Guest’s Slip and Fall Injuries; Guest Loses

Target store at 5900 Lake Worth Road, in Greenacres, Florida
Target store at 5900 Lake Worth Road, in Greenacres, Florida

Benita Siciliano claimed that she slipped on a placemat lying face-down on the floor of a Target store and fell.  She alleged that she sustained serious injuries to her back and neck.

She said that it happened at the Target store at 5900 Lake Worth Road, in Greenacres, Florida.

Her Attorney demanded $950,000 from Target

Her attorney made a settlement demand to Bart Olson of Sedgwick Claims Management for Target.  The demand was for $950,000.00.

Her settlement demand letter detailed the extent of her injuries, the physicians who treated her, and the medical care she received.

The demand letter documented treatment with twelve (12) different medical providers with total medicals expenses of $204,401.99.

She Claimed Disc Herniations in Her Neck and Back

Her settlement demand documents cervical disc herniations at C5/C6 and C6/C7 and a lumbar disc herniation at L4/L5 with disc bulge at L5/S1 stated on an MRI.  In other words, she claimed two herniated discs in her neck and a herniated disc in her back.

She had a Spinal Fusion Surgery in Her Neck

Her settlement demand said that she underwent anterior spinal fusion surgery at the C5/6 level with anterior instrumentation, partial corpectomy and insertion of interbody cage at C5/6.

Benita Siciliano, sued Target on November 18, 2014.  Target removed the case to Federal Court in West Palm Beach, Florida.

What compensation did she sue for?

In addition to total medicals expenses of $204,401.99, she sued for compensation for

  • Past Lost Income
  • Future lost income reduced to present value
  • Future medical expenses
  • Emotional and physical past pain and suffering
  • Emotional and Future Pain and Suffering
  • Loss of capacity for the enjoyment of life

She claimed that she slipped and fell as a result of the negligence of Target Corporation (“Target”) and the acting manager of the Target store in which she fell.

Target tried to get the case dismissed

On November 25, 2014, Target tried to get the case dismissed.  The court rejected Target’s request.  I talk more about this below.

Florida Law for Slip and Falls

Under Florida law, “if a person slips and falls on a transitory substance in a business establishment, the injured person must prove that the business establishment had actual or constructive knowledge of the dangerous condition and should have taken action to remedy it.” Fla. Stat. § 768.0755(1).

Absent evidence of actual knowledge, constructive knowledge may be proven by circumstantial evidence showing that:

(a) the dangerous condition existed for such a length of time that, in the exercise of ordinary care, the business establishment should have known of the condition; or

(b) the condition occurred with regularity and was therefore foreseeable.

Facts of the Case

The guest and her son were shopping for school supplies in the seasonal “back-to-school” section of the Lake Worth Target store when she slipped on a placemat lying face-down on the floor and fell.

She couldn’t show that Target had actual knowledge of the placement on the floor prior to her fall.  She also couldn’t show that the placemat on which she slipped remained on the floor, before her fall, for such a length of time that Target should have known it was there.

Items Were Regularly on the Floor in Seasonal Area of Target

However, there was enough evidence—particularly in the testimony of Target store employees—to raise a genuine dispute as to the regularity with which items such as the placemat on which Siciliano slipped are left on the floor of the seasonal area of the store, where Siciliano fell, during the back-to-school season.

Target wasn’t aware of placements being on floor before fall

The testimony of Target store employees established that, prior to Siciliano’s fall, they had never seen or heard of a placemat on the floor, and knew of no one else who had slipped and fallen on a placemat or other object left on the floor of the store’s seasonal section.

Seasonal Section was Often Messy

Yet, their testimony also established that during the back-to-school season, the store’s seasonal section is often messy.  The employees’ testimony also established that  customers tend to throw items on the floor and leave them there, and this was not the first time Target store employees had seen items on the floor in the back-to-school section.

This evidence raised a genuine dispute as to whether items were regularly left on the floor of the store’s seasonal back-to-school section, which is important to the extent that Siciliano may offer evidence of the regularity with which this condition occurred to prove that Target had constructive knowledge of the placemat on the floor in this particular case.

Items Regularly on Floor Gets to a Jury

The Court said that section 768.0755 does not require that placemats such as the one on which Siciliano slipped in this case are regularly left on the floor of the store’s seasonal back-to-school section in order to prove that Target had constructive knowledge of that condition in this case.

So long as items were regularly on the floor before the fall, that was good enough to show constructive notice.

This is a good case for people who are injured at stores.  Similar facts may allow your case to get to trial.

However, Siciliano’s luck ran out…

Jury Says Target Didn’t Cause Shopper’s Injuries

The jury found that Target’s negligence wasn’t the cause of the shopper’s injuries.  She lost the case.

What law firm did Target use?

Target used the West Palm Beach law firm of Derrevere, Hawkes, et. al.  Target pays this firm by the hour to defend it in slip and fall cases.

The case is Benita Siciliano vs. Target Corporation.  Date of Verdict: May 29, 2015.

Case No.: 9:14-CV-80459.  The judges were Rosenberg/Brannon.  This isn’t my case though I have settled many Florida slip and fall cases.

Call Me Now!

Call me now at (888) 594-3577 to find out for FREE if we can represent you. We answer calls 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year. 

No Fees or Costs if We Do Not Get You Money

No Fees or Costs if We don't get you money.

We speak Spanish. We invite you to learn more about us.

Related

Filed Under: Slip, Trip and Fall

I will not become your attorney by you leaving a comment. There is a time limit to file a lawsuit. All comments will be public. This includes the name that you enter. I only represent people who were hurt in Florida or on a cruise ship; or if the injured person lives in Florida or a family member (in the case of a death) lives in Florida. This is because I am only licensed in Florida.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Serving Florida

Get a Free Consultation. JZ helps (a Florida injury law firm)

Get a Free Consult Now

Complete this form to see if I can represent you. We usually respond fast.

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
MM slash DD slash YYYY
We only represent people for injury or death that happened in Florida (or on a cruise). However, if you live in Florida and the incident happened in another state, we may be able to represent you.
If your accident did NOT happen in Florida or on a cruise, and you don't live in Florida, I likely won't be able to represent you.
Select your most serious injury.
For example, damage to a car(s), hazard that you tripped on, incident scene, crash report, major scarring, etc.
Drop files here or
Max. file size: 50 MB.
    By submitting this form I agree to the Terms of Use.

    We’re Open!

    No Fees or Costs if No Recovery

    Florida Injury Lawyer

    Personal injury lawyer Justin "JZ" Ziegler has recovered over $15 Million in settlements for people seriously hurt in accidents in Florida (or on a cruise).

    We want to represent you. Our office is in Coral Gables (Miami-Dade County), Florida. However, we can meet you anywhere in Florida. Call (888) 594-3577 for a Free Consultation Now!

    Search

    Florida Injury Case Types

    • Auto Accident Claims
    • Cruise Accident Claims
    • Florida Motor Vehicle No-Fault Law, Personal Injury Protection (PIP)
    • Foot and Ankle Injury Claims
    • Hand & Wrist Injury Claims
    • Herniated Disc Claims
    • Lyft accidents
    • Personal Injury
    • Premises Liability
    • Shoulder Injury Claims
    • Slip, Trip and Fall
    • Spinal Injuries
    • Truck Accident Claims
    • Uber Accidents
    • Uninsured Motorist Claims
    • Wrongful Death Claims

    Connect With Us

    • Facebook
    • YouTube

    2010

    Super Lawyers

    2005 & 2006 Up & Coming 

    Interviewed by:

    WSVN 7 Miami

    Miami Herald

    NBC6

    CNNwall street journalQuoted in:
    Miami New TimesTBO - Tampa Tribune

    Telegraph

    Member of:Florida Justice Association

    Florida Justice Association, and Florida Bar

    Subscribe to Blog via Email

    Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    We Handle:

    Car accidents, slip and falls, motorcycle accidents, Uber accidents and more.

    We’ve settled many cases with GEICO, State Farm, Progressive, USAA and others.

    We’ve settled cases for people who’ve injured their shoulder, hand, broken a leg, arm, foot and much more.

    Disclaimers

    Follow Us

    • Facebook
    • YouTube

    Attorney Justin “JZ” Ziegler

    Get a Free Consultation Now!

    We’ve had over $11 million in injury settlements for accidents in Miami, Homestead, Hialeah and throughout Florida.

    We’ve settled many personal injury claims in Miami.  However, we’ve also settled cases throughout the entire state of Florida.  This includes several settlements for over $195,000 for accidents that happened in Fort Lauderdale, the Orlando area, Clearwater, Pensacola and other cities.

    Contact Us

    JZ helps (a Florida injury law firm)
    1450 Madruga Ave., Suite 306B
    Coral Gables, Florida 33146

    Our office is near the University of Miami.  Serving all of Florida.

    1-888-JZ-Helps (1-888-594-3577) or 305-661-9977

    24 hours / 7 days a week

    En Español

    We’re also proud of our results in other parts of the state (as well as the Miami area).  Therefore, I call myself a Miami injury lawyer who serves all of Florida.

    Copyright © 2023 · JZ helps (a Florida injury law firm)