JZ helps (a Florida injury law firm)

Call Now! (888) 594-3577Get a Free Consultation - 24 / 7
Se habla Español
Call Now! (888) 594-3577
Get a Free Consultation - 24 / 7
Se habla Español


  • Home
  • Videos
  • Blog
  • Settlements
    • Florida Injury Settlements
    • Car Accident Settlements
    • Motorcycle Accidents Settlements
    • Uber Accidents
    • Slip, Trip & Fall Settlements
    • Bike Accident Settlements
    • GEICO Car Accident Settlements
    • Pedestrian Hit By Car Settlements
    • Uninsured Motorist Insurance Settlements
    • Cruise Accident Settlements
    • DUI Accident Settlements
    • Truck Accident Settlements
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • See Inside
    • Types of Injuries We’ve Dealt With
    • List of Cities Where We’ve Settled Cases
    • Press Room
  • Fees
    • Our Fees
    • Referral Fees
  • Cases We Handle
    • All personal injury cases
    • Car Accidents
    • Truck Accidents
    • Uber Accidents
    • Slip and Falls and Injuries on Property
    • Cruise Accidents
    • Florida Motorcycle Accidents
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • Accidents at a Store
    • DUI Accidents
    • Accidental or Wrongful Death
    • Florida Condo and Apartment Accidents
    • Hotel Accidents
  • Get a Free Case Review
  • Reviews
You are here: Home / Cruise Accident Claims / Carnival Cruise Slip and Fall Case Dismissed for Failure to Sue in Time

August 29, 2015 By Justin Ziegler, Lawyer Leave a Comment

Carnival Cruise Slip and Fall Case Dismissed for Failure to Sue in Time

Carnival Breeze - Copy

In Pettit v. Carnival Corporation, Dist. Court, SD Florida 2015, Rebecca Pettit sued Carnival Corporation for a slip and fall accident.  Carnival Corporation is the legal name for Carnival Cruise Lines.  

As required by Carnival’s passenger ticket contract, Pettit’s attorney sued in United States District Court, S.D. Florida, Miami Division.  This is federal court.

Tip: Not every Florida attorney is licensed to practice in Federal Court.

On August 10, 2015, the judge entered an order granting Carnival’s Motion for Summary Judgment.  This means that the judge permanently dismissed the case.

Carnival asked the court to dismiss the case on the basis that Petit filed her lawsuit which states a claim for personal injury due to Carnival’s alleged negligence, outside of the one-year statute of limitations provided for by her ticket contract.

A statute of limitations is a time limit within which you must sue, or your claim is forever lost.

Fact: In a personal injury claim against Carnival or any cruise line, you must show that they were negligent.  If Carnival did nothing wrong that caused your injury, you get nothing.

In response, Pettit argued that the limitations period should be equitably extended, and that genuine disputes of material facts should prevent dismissal of the case.

Background

The following facts are agreed upon:

Pettit was a passenger aboard the Carnival Breeze when she was injured in a slip-and-fall incident on September 24, 2013.

Prior to embarking on Breeze, Pettit completed a Guest Ticket Contract Acknowledgement, in which she agreed that she viewed and had an opportunity to read all the terms and conditions as stated in the contract and that she understood and accepted all such terms and conditions.

The ticket contract contains a forum selection clause, naming the Southern District of Florida (in Miami, Florida) as the appropriate venue (location) for this lawsuit.  It also had a statute of limitations, which provides that any claim for personal injury “shall not be maintainable unless filed within one year after the date of injury.”

On September 12, 2014, only twelve days before the deadline under the one year statute of limitations, Pettit sued suit in state court for Miami-Dade County, Florida.

Warning: Never wait until twelve (12) days before a deadline to sue.  In fact, you may want to sue within ninety (90) days prior to the expiration of the statute of limitations.

On the flip side, I will say that since Carnival is sued so often (relative to Miami “mom and pop stores”), cruise accident lawyers know Carnival’s legal name.  There should not be any issue with naming them properly as strictly required by the law.

Tip: Carnival may agree to enter to extend the statute of limitations.  They can do this because its 1 year statute of limitations is created by their contract.  If you agree, get it in writing, preferably by Carnival’s claims manager and their attorney.  This is because those individuals can legally bind Carnival to this contract extension.

Pettit did not serve Carnival until nearly two months later, on November 11, 2014.  Carnival timely filed its first and only answer to the lawsuit on December 1, 2014, in which Carnival asked the state court to dismiss the lawsuit based on the terms of the forum selection clause contained in the ticket contract.

Thereafter, on December 17, 2014, Pettit filed her lawsuit in Federal Court in Miami, Florida.

Standard on Summary Judgment Dismissal

The court should only dismiss the case if there is no genuine dispute about a material fact.

Discussion

The passenger agreed that this lawsuit was filed outside the statute of limitations to which the parties bound themselves in the ticket contract.

Attempting to get around this obvious defect in her lawsuit, she asks the Court to equitably extend the statute of limitations, claiming genuine issues of material fact exist as to whether Defendant’s conduct unfairly caused her not to file suit in federal court.

She claims that Carnival:

1) failed to notify Plaintiff of its intention to enforce its clause that stated that lawsuits must be filed in Miami Federal Court, and

2) has repeatedly waived its defense of improper venue for claims under the $75,000 amount-in-controversy threshold of 18 U.S.C. § 1332.

Equitable tolling refers to the law that permits a court to extend a statute of limitations where the court finds that an inequitable event has prevented her timely lawsuit.

Examples of inequitable events include cases where:

  • a cruise line misleads the passenger into allowing the statutory period to lapse
  • the passenger has no reasonable way of discovering the wrong perpetrated against him or her, or
  • the passenger timely files a technically defective lawsuit complaint, but in all other respects acts with the proper diligence that the limitation period is intended to insure.

Those examples were cited in the slip and fall case of Psurny v. Royal Caribbean Cruises, Ltd., 926 F. Supp. 2d 1325, 1328-29 (S.D. Fla. 2013).

Monarch of the Seas
Royal Caribbean’s Monarch of the Seas from the Psurny case.

Learn about Royal Caribbean Cruise slip and fall accidents.

The burden is on the passenger to demonstrate that equitable tolling is appropriate, and equitable tolling is not available to a passenger who fails to sue in time despite knowing that the deadline is running.

Back to the Pettit vs. Carnival case…

The judge said that extending the statute of limitations is not appropriate. The forum selection clause clearly states that all lawsuits should take place in the Southern District of Florida…

Carnival is not alleged to have taken any action in this case which would have suggested to Pettit that Carnival was waiving the forum selection clause in the ticket contract.  Claims in admiralty are not subject to section 1332’s amount-in-controversy requirement.

Moreover, Pettit sued in state court only twelve days before the running of her contractual statute of limitations, and failed to serve her lawsuit upon Carnival for nearly sixty days thereafter.

Accordingly, the fact that Pettit initially sued in state court, and that Carnival moved to dismiss her state court lawsuit on the basis of improper venue (court) only after the statute of limitations had run, was a product of “garden variety” negligence on the part of Pettit’s attorney. See Crist v. Carnival Corp., 410 F. App’x 197, 203 (11th Cir. 2010).

Court rarely extends time to sue in cruise injury cases

Thus, the judge said that she has failed to carry her burden of showing unfair conduct on the part of Carnival sufficient to justify the extraordinary remedy of equitable tolling.

The court dismissed the case.  The passenger lost her claim against Carnival.

Bottom Line

In a personal injury case against Carnival Cruise Lines, you must sue Carnival in federal court in Miami.  If you think that you may be able to settle the case, get a written extension from Carnival’s claims manager and/or attorney.  You may still want to file your lawsuit, but not serve them.

Do not count on a judge extending your time limit to sue them.  The one year time period to sue goes quickly.  Start requesting all of your medical records and bills immediately.

Send them to Carnival’s claims adjuster immediately.

Want to Learn more about Carnival Cruise Line Accident Claims?

Check out these 7 must see articles:

  • Carnival Cruise Passenger Gets $2,998,155 for 6 Knee Surgeries from Slip and Fall
  • Carnival Cruise Slip and Fall Accident Claims
  • Carnival Cruise Slip and Fall on Condensation or Slippery Tile Claim
  • $7,500 Verdict for Carnival Cruise Slip and Fall on Oily Substance
  • Passenger’s Slip and Fall on Carnival Cruise Dismissed Where No Substance on Floor
  • Carnival Doesn’t Have to Give Past Incident Reports of Hazard that Caused Your Fall
  • Court Lets Slip and Fall on Wet and Slippery Substance Go Forward vs. Carnival

I want to represent you if you were hurt in an accident on a Carnival cruise ship, or another cruise line or somewhere else in Florida.

Call Us Now!

Call us now at (888) 594-3577 to find out for FREE if we can represent you. We answer calls 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year. 

No Fees or Costs if We Do Not Get You Money

Miami and Florida Injury Cases Attorney No Fees or Costs if We don't get you money.

We speak Spanish. I invite you to learn more about us.

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Email

Related

Filed Under: Cruise Accident Claims

Get a Free Consultation. JZ helps (a Florida injury law firm)
I will not become your attorney by you leaving a comment. There is a time limit to file a lawsuit. All comments will be public. This includes the name that you enter. I only represent people who were hurt in Florida or on a cruise ship; or if the injured person lives in Florida or a family member (in the case of a death) lives in Florida. This is because I am only licensed in Florida.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Serving Florida

Get a Free Consultation. JZ helps (a Florida injury law firm)

Get a Free Consult

Fill out this form to see if we can represent you. We'll respond in minutes.
  • Date Format: MM slash DD slash YYYY
  • By submitting this form I agree to the Terms of Use.

We’re Open!

No Fees or Costs if No Recovery

Florida Injury Lawyer

Injury lawyer Justin "JZ" Ziegler has recovered over $8 Million in settlements for people hurt in accidents in Florida (or on a cruise).

We want to represent you. Our office is in Coral Gables (Miami-Dade County), Florida. However, we can meet you anywhere in Florida. Call (888) 594-3577 for a Free Consultation Now!

Search

Florida Injury Case Types

  • Auto Accident Claims
  • Cruise Accident Claims
  • Florida Motor Vehicle No-Fault Law, Personal Injury Protection (PIP)
  • Foot and Ankle Injury Claims
  • Hand & Wrist Injury Claims
  • Herniated Disc Claims
  • Lyft accidents
  • Personal Injury
  • Premises Liability
  • Shoulder Injury Claims
  • Slip, Trip and Fall
  • Spinal Injuries
  • Truck Accident Claims
  • Uber Accidents
  • Uninsured Motorist Claims
  • Wrongful Death Claims

Connect With Us

  • Facebook
  • YouTube

2010

Super Lawyers

2005 & 2006 Up & Coming 

Interviewed by:NBC6

CNNwall street journalQuoted in:
Miami New TimesTBO - Tampa Tribune

Telegraph

Member of:Florida Justice Association

Florida Justice Association, and Florida Bar

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

We Handle:

Car accidents, slip and falls, motorcycle accidents, Uber accidents and more.

We’ve settled cases with GEICO, State Farm, Progressive, USAA and others.

We’ve settled cases for people who’ve injured their shoulder, hand, broken a leg, arm, foot and much more.

Disclaimers

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Attorney Justin “JZ” Ziegler

Get a Free Consultation Now!

We’ve had over $8 million in injury settlements for accidents in Miami, Homestead, Hialeah and throughout Florida.

We’ve settled many personal injury claims in Miami.  However, we’ve also settled cases throughout the entire state of Florida.  This includes several $185K+ settlements for accidents that happened in Fort Lauderdale, the Orlando area, Clearwater, Pensacola and other cities.

Contact Us

JZ helps (a Florida injury law firm)
1450 Madruga Ave., Suite 200
Coral Gables, Florida 33146

Our office is near the University of Miami.  Serving all of Florida.

1-888-JZ-Helps (1-888-594-3577) or 305-661-9977

24 hours / 7 days a week

En Español

We’re also proud of our results in other parts of the state (as well as the Miami area).  Therefore, I call myself a Miami injury lawyer who serves all of Florida.

Copyright © 2019 · JZ helps (a Florida injury law firm)

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.