JZ helps (a Florida injury law firm)

Call Now! (888) 594-3577Get a Free Consultation - 24 / 7
Se habla Español
Call Now! (888) 594-3577
Get a Free Consultation - 24 / 7
Se habla Español


  • Home
  • Videos
  • Blog
  • Settlements
    • Injury Settlements
    • Car Accident Settlements
    • GEICO Car Accident Settlements
    • State Farm Settlements
    • Rear End Car Accident Settlements
    • Progressive Insurance Settlements
    • Motorcycle Accidents Settlements
    • Uber Accidents
    • Slip, Trip & Fall Settlements
    • Bike Accident Settlements
    • Pedestrian Hit By Car Settlements
    • Uninsured Motorist Insurance Settlements
    • Truck Accident Settlements
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • See Inside
    • Types of Injuries We’ve Dealt With
    • List of Cities Where We’ve Settled Cases
    • Press Room
  • Fees
    • Our Fees
    • Referral Fees
  • Cases We Handle
    • All personal injury cases
    • Car Accidents
    • Truck Accidents
    • Uber Accidents
    • Slip and Falls and Injuries on Property
    • Cruise Accidents
    • Florida Motorcycle Accidents
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • Accidents at a Store
    • DUI Accidents
    • Accidental or Wrongful Death
    • Florida Condo and Apartment Accidents
    • Hotel Accidents
  • Get a Free Case Review
  • Reviews
You are here: Home / Auto Accident Claims / Florida Motor Vehicle Owner Only Liable for $600,000 for Motorcyclist Brain Injuries

July 2, 2015 By Justin Ziegler, Lawyer Leave a Comment

Florida Motor Vehicle Owner Only Liable for $600,000 for Motorcyclist Brain Injuries

Damage to front and driver side of Chevrolet Silverado truck.
Not actual motor vehicle from case.

In De Los Santos v. Brink, Fla: Dist. Court of Appeals, 5th Dist. 2015, Dustin C. Brink sued Juan Ruiz De Los Santos and Juan L. Ruiz Pereles.

As a result of a collision with a motor vehicle owned by Juan Ruiz De Los Santos (“Santos”), and operated by Juan L. Ruiz Pereles (“Pereles”), Dustin Brink (who was riding a motorcycle) suffered serious brain injuries.  I do not know if Santos’ motor vehicle was a truck or car.

His negligence lawsuit against Pereles and Santos went to trial, where the jury gave a verdict for damages of over $25 million. After consideration of Brink’s comparative negligence and calculation of collateral source setoffs and costs, the trial court ultimately entered a final judgment against Santos and Pereles for $12,832,837.17, with language providing that Brink’s recovery against Santos was “subject to the limitations of Santo’s responsibility pursuant to section 324.021(9)(b)3, Florida Statutes.”

This means that even though the jury verdict awarded $25 million, Brink was apparently also at fault.  In Florida, your damages are reduced proportionately with your percentage of fault.

I do not know Brink’s percentage of comparative fault.  But, for example, if Brink was 50% at fault, he would be entitled to recover 50% of the damages.  In Florida, even if you over 51% at fault, you can still recover damages.

In Florida, your total damages are reduced by collateral source setoffs.

Collateral sources are benefits received or payments made by collateral sources of indemnity.  In Florida, a defendant is allowed to reduce a jury verdict by the total amounts which have been paid for the benefit of the claimant, or which are otherwise available to the claimant, from all collateral sources.

However, there shall be no reduction for collateral sources for which a subrogation or reimbursement right exists.  Contractual discounts are considered collateral sources.  Goble v. Frohman, 901 So.2d 830. 

Let’s assume that the motorcycle rider had private health insurance that it received $1,000,000 in billed medical charges, but due to contractual discounts only paid $500,000 of his medical expenses.

Assume that the jury awarded the full $1,000,000 in medical bills.  The motorcyclist would only be able to recover the $500,000 that the health insurer paid.  This assumes that the health insurer had a right of subrogation.

If the health insurer did not have a right of subrogation, the motorcyclist would not be entitled to recover these medical bills.  This would be because he would not have to repay the health insurer.

Santos’ liability was solely vicarious and that Pereles had insurance with limits less than $500,000 combined property damage and bodily injury liability.

This means that the owner was only liable because he loaned the motor vehicle to Pereles, the user, in Florida.  In this case, the owner did not do anything wrong.

As a result, the parties agreed that Santos’ liability was limited to $600,000, plus costs and interest.  The motorcycle rider’s attorney agreed to this $600,000 limit because Florida law limits his liability to $600,000.

Section 324.021(9)(b)3., Florida Statutes states:

“The owner who is a natural person and loans a motor vehicle to any permissive user shall be liable for the operation of the vehicle or the acts of the operator in connection therewith only up to $100,000 per person and up to $300,000 per incident for bodily injury and up to $50,000 for property damage.

If the permissive user of the motor vehicle is uninsured or has any insurance with limits less than $500,000 combined property damage and bodily injury liability, the owner shall be liable for up to an additional $500,000 in economic damages only arising out of the use of the motor vehicle. The additional specified liability of the owner for economic damages shall be reduced by amounts actually recovered from the permissive user and from any insurance or self-insurance covering the permissive user. Nothing in this subparagraph shall be construed to affect the liability of the owner for his or her own negligence.”

The appeals court said that the final judgment against Santos’ should be limited to $600,000.

My thoughts: The jury issued a huge verdict because the motorcycle rider had severe brain injuries.  They also found the motorcyclist to be partially at fault and reduced his damages due to contractual discounts on his medical bills.

In Florida, motorcyclists are often found to be partially at fault in an accident.  Witnesses often say that the motorcycle rider was speeding.

After taking those factors into account, the total judgment against the vehicle driver was still huge ($12,832,837.17).  However, since the owner did nothing wrong, he is only liable for $600,000.

The motorcyclist will likely only collect this $600,000 judgement (or anything close to it) if:

1. The owner or driver has a large bodily injury (BI) liability auto insurance policy; or

2. The owner and/or driver’s auto insurer failed to act in good faith and settle the case when it could and should have.

This is because in Florida, BI liability coverage is not required on private passenger motor vehicles.  A private passenger vehicle is a non-commercial vehicle.

When a natural person (not a corporation) has BI coverage, it is usually not more than $100,000.  It is often much less.

The vehicle driver is still responsible for the entire judgment because his negligence caused the motorcyclist’s severe brain injuries.

The District Court of Appeal of Florida, Fifth District issued an opinion on July 2, 2015. The Fifth District Court of Appeal is comprised of Hernando, Lake, Marion, Citrus and Sumter Counties; Flagler, Putnam, St. Johns and Volusia Counties; Orange and Osceola Counties; and Brevard and Seminole Counties.

Therefore, I assume that this accident happened in one of these counties.  Fort Lauderdale and Orlando, Florida lawyers represented Brink.  This not my case.

However, this case helps any motorcycle or motor vehicle injury victim better understand Florida personal injury law.  (I have settled many Florida motorcycle accident cases.)

A Tampa lawyer and Orlando attorney represented the defendants.

Call Us Now!

Call us now at (888) 594-3577 to find out for FREE if we can represent you. We answer calls 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year. 

No Fees or Costs if We Do Not Get You Money

Zero Fee or costs if no recovery

We speak Spanish. We invite you to learn more about us.

Related

Filed Under: Auto Accident Claims

I will not become your attorney by you leaving a comment. There is a time limit to file a lawsuit. All comments will be public. This includes the name that you enter. I only represent people who were hurt in Florida or on a cruise ship; or if the injured person lives in Florida or a family member (in the case of a death) lives in Florida. This is because I am only licensed in Florida.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Serving Florida

Get a Free Consultation. JZ helps (a Florida injury law firm)

Get a Free Consult Now

Complete this form to see if I can represent you. We usually respond fast.

"*" indicates required fields

MM slash DD slash YYYY
We only represent people for injury or death that happened in Florida (or on a cruise). However, if you live in Florida and the incident happened in another state, we may be able to represent you.
If your accident did NOT happen in Florida or on a cruise, and you don't live in Florida, I likely won't be able to represent you.
Select your most serious injury.
By submitting this form I agree to the Terms of Use.

We’re Open!

No Fees or Costs if No Recovery

Florida Injury Lawyer

Injury lawyer Justin "JZ" Ziegler has recovered over $11 Million in settlements for people seriously hurt in accidents in Florida (or on a cruise).

We want to represent you. Our office is in Coral Gables (Miami-Dade County), Florida. However, we can meet you anywhere in Florida. Call (888) 594-3577 for a Free Consultation Now!

Search

Florida Injury Case Types

  • Auto Accident Claims
  • Cruise Accident Claims
  • Florida Motor Vehicle No-Fault Law, Personal Injury Protection (PIP)
  • Foot and Ankle Injury Claims
  • Hand & Wrist Injury Claims
  • Herniated Disc Claims
  • Lyft accidents
  • Personal Injury
  • Premises Liability
  • Shoulder Injury Claims
  • Slip, Trip and Fall
  • Spinal Injuries
  • Truck Accident Claims
  • Uber Accidents
  • Uninsured Motorist Claims
  • Wrongful Death Claims

Connect With Us

  • Facebook
  • YouTube

2010

Super Lawyers

2005 & 2006 Up & Coming 

Interviewed by:

WSVN 7 Miami

Miami Herald

NBC6

CNNwall street journalQuoted in:
Miami New TimesTBO - Tampa Tribune

Telegraph

Member of:Florida Justice Association

Florida Justice Association, and Florida Bar

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

We Handle:

Car accidents, slip and falls, motorcycle accidents, Uber accidents and more.

We’ve settled many cases with GEICO, State Farm, Progressive, USAA and others.

We’ve settled cases for people who’ve injured their shoulder, hand, broken a leg, arm, foot and much more.

Disclaimers

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • YouTube

Attorney Justin “JZ” Ziegler

Get a Free Consultation Now!

We’ve had over $11 million in injury settlements for accidents in Miami, Homestead, Hialeah and throughout Florida.

We’ve settled many personal injury claims in Miami.  However, we’ve also settled cases throughout the entire state of Florida.  This includes several settlements for over $195,000 for accidents that happened in Fort Lauderdale, the Orlando area, Clearwater, Pensacola and other cities.

Contact Us

JZ helps (a Florida injury law firm)
1450 Madruga Ave., Suite 306B
Coral Gables, Florida 33146

Our office is near the University of Miami.  Serving all of Florida.

1-888-JZ-Helps (1-888-594-3577) or 305-661-9977

24 hours / 7 days a week

En Español

We’re also proud of our results in other parts of the state (as well as the Miami area).  Therefore, I call myself a Miami injury lawyer who serves all of Florida.

Copyright © 2022 · JZ helps (a Florida injury law firm)